In the field of cold chain logistics and fresh food processing, the choice of ice making machine equipment directly affects preservation efficiency, operating costs, and sustainability. For enterprises that require stable ice making capabilities, the comparison between air-cooled and water-cooled tube ice machines often becomes the core contradiction in procurement decisions.
机翻 · 通用领域
Technical principle: The "underlying logic" of two cooling paths
1. Air cooled tube ice machine: a "plug and play" solution for air circulation
Core principle: The refrigerant is circulated and compressed by a compressor, and after being cooled by a condenser, heat exchange is achieved through forced air convection by a fan.
• Technical features:
No need for water source: suitable for areas with water shortage or poor water quality (such as inland, island fishing ports);
Compact structure: reduces footprint by 30%, making it easier to layout small and medium-sized cold storage facilities with limited space;
• Easy maintenance: only need to regularly clean the heat dissipation fins and filters, with a lower failure rate than the water cooling system.
• Typical disadvantages:
• Environmental sensitivity: High temperature or high humidity environments may lead to a 20% decrease in heat dissipation efficiency;
• Long term energy consumption: The operation and frequent start stop of the fan may increase power consumption, with an average annual electricity cost about 15% higher than that of water cooling.
2. Water cooled tube ice machine: the "high-performance king" of water circulation
• Core principle: By circulating water through a cooling tower or water tank as a refrigerant, the heat of the refrigerant is transferred to the water, and then dissipated through evaporation or external cooling systems.
• Technical features:
• Efficient and stable: Under constant water source conditions, the ice making efficiency is increased by 25% -30%, suitable for continuous high-intensity operation;
• Energy saving advantages: Water has a high specific heat capacity, reducing unit energy consumption by 18% -22% and lowering long-term costs;
Accurate temperature control: It can achieve a fine adjustment of ± 0.5 ℃, suitable for high-end scenarios with strict requirements for ice sheet thickness (such as live seafood transportation).
• Typical disadvantages:
Water source dependence: requires stable water supply, and high water hardness can easily lead to pipeline scaling;
• Complex maintenance: Regular cleaning of the cooling tower and anti rust medication are required, increasing maintenance costs by 30% -40%;
• Space requirement: The cooling system takes up a large amount of space, with a total footprint 50% larger than that of air cooling.
Scenario based selection: "Applicable maps" for air cooling and water cooling
1. Air cooled: the "best partner" for small and medium-sized enterprises and extreme environments
• Applicable scenarios:
Light asset operation: small and medium-sized aquatic processing plants, township level cold chain logistics centers;
• Water scarce areas
• Emergency scenarios: temporary freezer, mobile fresh food delivery vehicles.
2. Water cooling: the "optimal solution" for scale and high stability requirements
• Applicable scenarios:
Large scale cold chain hub: provincial cold chain logistics center, pre warehouse cluster for fresh e-commerce;
• Precise temperature control scenario: laboratory sample transportation, refrigeration of high-end ingredients (such as Wagyu beef and rare seafood);
• Environmental compliance zone: an area that meets wastewater recycling standards (such as EU certified factories).
Selection Decision: Four Key Indicators and Cost Model
| Dimension | Core advantages of air-cooled | Core advantages of water-cooled |
| Initial investment | Low (about 150000 to 250000) | High (about 300000 to 500000) |
| Maintenance cost | Low (annual maintenance fee ≤ 5% of total cost) | High (annual maintenance fee about 10% -15%) |
| Environmental adaptation | No dependence on water sources, excellent performance in low-temperature environments | Requires stable water sources, more efficient in high-temperature environments |
| Energy Efficiency Ratio | Moderate (COP 3.0-3.5) | High (COP 4.0-4.8) |
Air cooled and water-cooled tube ice machines are not an either or choice, but require comprehensive consideration of multiple factors such as enterprise scale, environmental conditions, and cost structure.
Hot Tags: cbfi tube ice machine selection: air-cooled and water-cooled, China, manufacturer, factory, price, buy, commercial tube ice machine, ice tube maker machine, , tube ice machine, tube ice maker machine, tube ice making machine
